For owners selling a Chocolate Hole parcel and for prospective buyers, the Estate Chocolate Hole Landowners' Association provides a letter of good standing. It won't issue the letter until it has the buyer's name, email, mailing address and phone number. This letter is where the estate's money questions come up, and the amount owed on two parcels a short drive apart can differ a lot.
The association, known as ECHLA and formed in 1984, treats the estate as three sections for maintenance: Chocolate Hole East, North and West. Each section pays for its own roads, decides how much to charge, and gets back only what it pays in. Two parcels in the same subdivision, under the same association and on the same deed form, can carry very different road bills.
Three Sections, Three Road Assessments
ECHLA's 2026 annual meeting notes, posted in May, list the road assessments for each section:
| Section | 2026 road assessment |
|---|---|
| Chocolate Hole West | $800 |
| Chocolate Hole East | $1,500 |
| Chocolate Hole North, residents | $600 |
| Chocolate Hole North, properties with 12 or more weeks of rentals | $1,200 |
The road assessment is separate from the association's general dues. The bylaws posted on the ECHLA site are dated July 20, 2003, and set annual dues at $80 for an improved lot and $40 for an unimproved one. A lot counts as improved from the date its earth change permit is issued. That dues schedule is more than twenty years old. The road assessment is the larger figure, and it is the one that varies by section.
Why the Money Stays Where It Was Raised
The bylaws explain the gap. Road assessments are set on an equitable basis by a caucus of members in each section, voting at the annual meeting, subject to approval by the directors. They are "accounted for separately by the Association" and "spent by the Association solely for work in the area from which those assessments are collected."
So the assessment reflects what one section's members voted to spend on their own roads. The East section's rate pays for a specific list of repairs. In March, ECHLA posted its 2026 Chocolate East road plan, which put roughly $150,000 toward paving in summer and fall 2026. The Stone Masonry bid, dated September 4 and signed September 9, itemizes $129,000 of East work:
- $8,900 to straighten the curb at the corner entrance from South Side into Chocolate East and remove the bow-out that drivers heading toward town turn left around
- $70,500 for three-quarters of the road width at the Tamarind, Hummingbird and Pond Bay entrance, a speed hump between the Pura Vida dip and the Pond Bay entrance, another speed hump downhill from Iguana, a drainage section with a grate on Beach Road, a 150-foot strip up to the Pura Vida driveway, and three steel bollards at the beach entrance near the Maho tree and sea grapes
- $15,000 for lower Devers/Bovocoap, including widening a section to the west and a 75-foot swale to carry water down toward Hart Bay
- $34,600 to replace a 137-foot stretch of Devers/Bovocoap heading up toward Scalini and Wings over Water
The contract sets the order of work: the Beach Road bollards and drain grate first, then the Bovocoap work, then the stretch from Pura Vida to Pond Bay and Hummingbird, including the entrance curb. At the September 8 meeting, the board reviewed road plans for East and West and set a tentative schedule that depended on concrete availability.
West has its own budget. In August, board members put West's road requests at about $95,000 against about $60,000 in the bank, with a concrete batch quote of $45,860. They also described the association's earlier practice of allocating road money by a formula based on cars served. The same minutes describe the middle section of Poinsettia as failing and note that it has been on the repair list for two years.
The sections have different road assessments, balances and repair queues.
The North Section Charges More for Rentals
The North section's assessment is the only one that changes with how a home is used. Properties with 12 or more weeks of rentals pay double the residents' rate.
The ECHLA warranty deed form addresses rentals and business use. It bans manufacturing, merchandising or "conduct of any trade, or business within the subdivision" outside lots designated HOTEL. It also says nothing in it prohibits an owner from "leasing or subleasing his private dwelling and/or guest quarters; however, only one set of guest quarters may be rented or leased if the principal house is occupied." The form limits each plot to one single-family house, with attached or detached guest quarters.
The association's Courtesy Code asks owners to share it with their guests and property managers. It covers outdoor lights, which should be off from midnight to dawn, and noise, which should be kept down from 9 PM to 8 AM. It also calls for on-site parking for residents, staff, service providers and guests, and says parking on estate roads is forbidden. On group events, it says:
"Rental homes should not be marketed as sites for events larger than the residence can sleep ... nor as sites for weddings or corporate retreats (rental homes should not be marketed in 'groupings' of homes – i.e. several villas rented to one group)."
The board still has this on its list. At the September 8 meeting, its legal concerns included "curbing of commercial activity in Chocolate Hole" and "2x separate rentals per parcels that exist and need to be contacted." Recorded deeds can differ from the form. The August minutes mention that one owner says his deed doesn't mention the association, and the board was interested in sampling deeds for HOA language. A buyer with rental plans may want counsel to compare the parcel's recorded deed with the form.
ECHLA's Building Code and Road Damage Deposits
ECHLA's Building Code, revised in February 2023, describes a road damage deposit for new construction and for major improvements that change a structure's footprint. The code says the deposit is 1% of the total cost of improvements as shown on the owner's DPNR permits, and must be paid before work starts. When the work is finished, the road committee chair for that section decides whether to refund it in full or in part, based on evidence of construction-related road damage. The code also limits construction to 7:00 A.M. to 6:00 P.M., Monday through Saturday, with no work on Sundays.
The deed form also addresses road repairs: it calls for an owner to promptly repair, at their own expense, any part of the estate roads damaged by equipment used to build on or improve their lot.
At the August 3 meeting, the board called the 1% fee "weakly enforced." The minutes say some owners never pay it, and that permit values can understate real spending. The example they gave was a permit valued at well under half of the project's estimated actual cost. The ideas raised included before-and-after photos, requiring a final section of road repair, and a flat construction assessment on sale or conversion, with no vote taken. The board held a redesign of the fee, comparing 1%, a flat fee and a last-segment road repair, for its November meeting.
So construction trucks wear down roads that the whole section pays to repair, and the deposit meant to cover that damage is tied to a permit figure that can run well below what the work actually costs.
What Comes Up at Closing
The bylaws address invoicing, past-due assessments, interest and liens. In August, the board discussed placing a lien on any owner more than two years behind instead of chasing balances at closing. It cited East assessments of about $1,820 a year at the time, which put the two-year mark at roughly $3,500. The same minutes report about $15,000 in owed dues collected from liens at a recent closing. The minutes describe these figures as spoken at the meeting, to be confirmed against the bookkeeper's reports.
ECHLA posts parcel maps for East, North and West.
ECHLA's next board meetings are scheduled for December 7, 2026 and January 4, 2027.
This post is general information drawn from the association's published documents. It is not legal, tax or financial advice, so please confirm how any covenant, assessment or lien applies to a specific parcel with your attorney or closing agent.
If you're weighing a Chocolate Hole parcel, especially one you plan to rent or build on, we're happy to go through which section it's in and what that section's road budget looks like. Bonvi Hospitality Group works on both the guest side and the ownership side here, so let's connect before the letter of good standing is requested.