Located just minutes east of Cruz Bay, Chocolate Hole is a established residential community built around two distinct coastal inlets—North Chocolate Hole and South Chocolate Hole. The neighborhood offers a peaceful, low-density atmosphere where paved roads wind past colorful hillside residences overlooking turquoise waters. Residents appreciate the quiet pebble beaches, excellent snorkeling along the rocky points, and close proximity to dining options at Hart Bay and Cruz Bay. Real estate in Chocolate Hole features custom Caribbean-style villas, masonry homes with expansive covered decks, and modern hillside retreats equipped with solar power and infinity pools. Single-family home prices typically range from $1.2 million to $3.5 million, with property values staying strong due to high demand for short-term vacation rentals. The steady market for homes for sale in Chocolate Hole attracts buyers looking for a quiet residential enclave that remains close to island conveniences. If you are assessing options across St John real estate, Chocolate Hole provides a compelling mix of accessibility and coastal tranquility. Reach out to Daniel Boudreau to explore private listings or schedule a home tour.
Search All Homes
